Affordable Home InsuranceHomeowners · condo · dwelling

Evansville, IN

Evansville, IN home insurance guide

What Evansville homeowners should know about coverage, costs, and local risks. A quote is not a binder.

In Evansville, 55% of households are homeowners, compared with 71% statewide. With roughly 115,395 people, the city has about 28,987 owner-occupied homes to insure.

Housing data for Evansville homeowners

IndicatorEvansvilleIndiana overall
Owner-occupied share55% (28,987)71%
Median home value$143,100$218,200
Median year built19611976
Single-family share of homes67%77%
Mobile/manufactured homes1%4%

Census Bureau figures: American Community Survey (2020–2024) and Vintage 2024 estimates.

What a Evansville home might cost to insure

With a median value of $143,100, Evansville sits below the state's $218,200. Land value is part of that number but is never rebuilt, which is why homeowners policies are set to reconstruction cost.

The closest public benchmark is the NAIC's 2023 average Indiana HO-3 premium of $786 for homes insured at Under $150,000. Statewide, HO-3 averaged $1,259.

Evansville homes by construction era

With a median construction year of 1961, a lot of Evansville housing has had at least one round of updates. Insurers want the years for roof, panel, water heater, and supply lines.

How Evansville stacks up in Indiana

Indianapolis: 56% owner-occupied, median value $224,800. In Fort Wayne, 62% of homes are owner-occupied and the median value is $188,900. Nearby Fishers has 76% homeowners and homes valued near $391,000. Evansville ranks 17th for homeownership among the 25 Indiana cities we cover in depth.

Coverage worth adding in Evansville

  • Ordinance or law coverage, because rebuilding a 1961-era home to current code can add real cost.
  • A water-backup endorsement for basements and lower levels.
  • Scheduled personal property for jewelry, art, or collectibles above standard sub-limits.

Storms, fire, and water in Evansville

Evansville homeowners share Indiana's main property risks, including tornadoes and derecho wind and spring and summer hail. Check your wind or hail deductible and whether water backup is endorsed.

See FEMA's National Risk Index for county-level hazard scores behind these themes.

What to have on hand in Evansville

  • Home address in Evansville plus living area
  • When the roof went on and what it is made of
  • System upgrades with dates
  • Liability features: pool, dog, trampoline
  • Present insurer, renewal date, and past claims
  • Mortgage company for the mortgagee clause

Start a Evansville home quote

Evansville homeowners insurance FAQ

What percentage of Evansville homes are owner-occupied?

About 55% of occupied homes in Evansville, roughly 28,987, are owner-occupied according to ACS 2020–2024 estimates.

What does homeowners insurance cost in Evansville?

It depends on the home and coverage. For context, the NAIC's 2023 Indiana HO-3 average was $1,259; see our Indiana page for averages by coverage amount.

Does a Evansville homeowners policy cover flooding?

No. Flood from surface water requires a separate NFIP or private flood policy.

More Indiana city guides

Home insurance in Indiana · Costs by state

Reviewed and updated October 15, 2026 · Our research methods