Affordable Home InsuranceHomeowners · condo · dwelling

Carlisle, PA

Insuring a home in Carlisle, PA

Home values, housing age, and weather exposure in Carlisle, plus how to request a quote. A quote is not a binder.

Roughly 4,491 households in Carlisle own the home they live in, which works out to 49% of occupied housing, a lower ownership rate compared with Pennsylvania as a whole (69%).

The numbers behind Carlisle homes

IndicatorCarlislePennsylvania overall
Owner-occupied share49% (4,491)69%
Median home value$224,100$254,500
Median year built19531965
Single-family share of homes62%75%
Mobile/manufactured homes0%4%

Census Bureau figures: American Community Survey (2020–2024) and Vintage 2024 estimates.

What a Carlisle home might cost to insure

Census data puts the median owner-occupied value in Carlisle at $224,100 (Pennsylvania: $254,500). Insurers will build their own replacement-cost estimate from square footage, finishes, and local labor rates; check that it captures any remodeling.

For HO-3 policies in the $200,000–$224,999 coverage range, the NAIC's 2023 Pennsylvania average premium was $832; the all-amounts HO-3 average was $1,217.

Carlisle homes by construction era

Homes here date back: the median Carlisle house was built in 1953. Ordinance or law coverage is worth a look, since rebuilding an older home to current code can cost more than the original.

Carlisle among Pennsylvania's larger cities

Philadelphia posts an ownership rate of 52% with a $243,100 median home value. In Pittsburgh, 48% of homes are owner-occupied and the median value is $205,800. In Allentown, 43% of homes are owner-occupied and the median value is $206,600. Carlisle ranks 16th for homeownership among the 30 Pennsylvania cities we cover in depth.

Filling coverage gaps on a Carlisle policy

  • Ordinance or law protection for code upgrades, which older Carlisle homes often need after a loss.
  • A water-backup endorsement for basements and lower levels.
  • Equipment breakdown for HVAC, water heaters, and appliances.

Carlisle hazards and the coverage that answers them

For a home in Carlisle, the Pennsylvania risks that matter most are basement flooding and drain backup, excluded unless endorsed and remnant hurricanes bringing wind and inland flooding. A percentage deductible or an exclusion can change what a claim pays.

Hazard themes summarize FEMA's National Risk Index and NOAA storm records; look up your county for detail.

Quote prep for Carlisle homeowners

  • Home address in Carlisle plus living area
  • Roof year and type
  • System upgrades with dates
  • Pool, trampoline, dogs, or wood stove
  • Current policy and five-year claims
  • Mortgage company for the mortgagee clause

Start a Carlisle home quote

Carlisle homeowners insurance FAQ

How many homeowners live in Carlisle?

About 49% of occupied homes in Carlisle, roughly 4,491, are owner-occupied according to ACS 2020–2024 estimates.

How much is an HO-3 policy in Carlisle?

It depends on the home and coverage. For context, the NAIC's 2023 Pennsylvania HO-3 average was $1,217; see our Pennsylvania page for averages by coverage amount.

Is flood included for Carlisle homes?

No. Flood from surface water requires a separate NFIP or private flood policy.

More Pennsylvania city guides

Home insurance in Pennsylvania · Costs by state

Reviewed and updated October 15, 2026 · Our research methods